This past Thursday was the Sunset Classic 5-miler in Bloomfield. My employer partly sponsors this race, so we always get a group together from work to run and share a pizza dinner afterward. It’s also a big draw for the local running community, with several clubs showing up in large numbers. Between my local running friends and my coworkers, it’s a fun night of familiar faces all gathered around my most precious hobby. What’s not to like?
Coming off the birth of my son earlier this year and the few months of uncomplicated training (and increased stress levels) that followed, I was apprehensive about this year’s race. In my last post, I wrote about the 30:56 I ran at Sunset 2023 as a possible benchmark, with my post-collegiate 5-mile best of 30:23 as an afterthought for a potential A-plus day. As the race got closer, setting up these goalposts almost felt like a mistake, as I had no idea what kind of shape I was in and had now given myself something to live up to. General apprehension turned into the specific, steady background hum of anxiety.
I tried to simplify: by the time the gun went off, my only goals were to get out in 6:15 for the first mile, get to the top of Sunset Ave without overextending myself, and see what happened after that.
What happened after that was I ran 29:51, which is the fastest I’ve run over that distance since I ran 8K (close enough) in 27:58 as a junior on my college cross country team. That was in 2011.
As I reflect on the race, I have several questions, and several plausible answers.
How did I misjudge my fitness by this much?
While I knew deep down I’d love to break 30 minutes on the Sunset course, I assumed that would be a goal for 2026 at best. Here, I was nervous about blowing up completely trying to break 31. Why was I so worried?
My first guess is I underestimated the impact of all the hill workouts I ran over the last several months, as well as the strides and strength work I put in. It wasn’t much, but I suppose it was more than doing nothing. I just thought it was closer to nothing than what I ended up getting out of it.
Also, Dad Strength is real. My shoulders and chest felt much better after five months of lugging my son around than they did when I was an office worker with no kids and no strength routine.
Speaking of my son, I think he was a big reason why I was keeping my expectations low. I didn’t want to be too aggressive and set myself up to fail (a mistake I nonetheless made right out of the gate). I didn’t want to strain against my new circumstances trying to do something I could try again at next year—but I also assumed that if I did strain, the circumstances would overpower me. Even with strong workouts coming in almost every week, I listened to that fear instead of the data.
It wasn’t just fear that I couldn’t be a dad and a runner at the same time, either. Thirty minutes is a nice round number, one I haven’t broken since I was in college and in close to the shape of my life. I like a nice round number when I’m changing the volume on my TV, or calculating the tip at a restaurant, but when running I find them intimidating. Round numbers ask questions of you. So, you think you’re a sub-30 guy?
Turns out I am, but I didn’t believe it on the starting line. Which raises the next question:
How did I run so much faster than expected despite my lack of confidence?
The short answer here is an unusually strong mental performance, but I want to elaborate because I finally noticed and put a name to a few things after this race.
First, I went into the race with a simple, action-oriented plan that made it easy to maintain a flexible and resilient racing mentality out on the course. The best races I have had over the last few years—my 4:58 mile in 2023 and my 2:52 marathon in Rehoboth come to mind, as well as this one—went as well as they did because I gave myself simple instructions: “compete more,” or “be patient,” or, in the case of Sunset, “go out in 6:15, climb the hill, and see what happens.”
People who talk about performance talk a lot about process-oriented goals, rather than outcome-oriented ones. Maybe I’m learning this a bit late at 33 years old, but they really do work.
There was something else I noticed about the instructions I gave myself on Thursday, the ones after I’d gotten to the “see what happens” part of the race plan. My self-talk was patient and gentle: “stay right here,” “don’t force it.” Maybe it’s me, but I always imagine the self-talk of a personal-best performance will sound like something out of Rocky.
That’s not to say I didn’t have moments where I was aggressive—namely, at the tops or bottoms of hills and other places on the course where I was naturally tempted to slow down, I looked at the runners ahead of me and stepped on the gas. It was important to keep going. After I got back up to pace, the gentle talk would return: “that’s enough,” “just keep rolling.”
If I were in a worse headspace, I might have panicked about the pace being too hot. Instead, I was calm and open-minded. “See what happens” left me a lot of room to work.
While it felt like a mistake leading up to the gun, setting a few different time goals also gave me a lot of room to work. I knew after three miles that I was going to blow past my course best. I knew after four that I was going to beat my post-collegiate best. It wasn’t until maybe four and a half miles that I really seriously considered pushing for sub-30. I think if that had been my goal from the beginning, I wouldn’t have made it.
With only 8 seconds to spare, I likely also wouldn’t have made it if the weather hadn’t been extremely favorable for a late-June evening race. After hitting the high nineties just a few days earlier, temperatures were in the low seventies by gun time. There was a light breeze. The humidity was tolerable—a miracle for summer in Jersey. Simply put, I will likely never have a night like that for the Sunset Classic ever again.
I’m glad I put myself in the best possible position to capitalize.
How should I adjust my goals for the future?
For the first time since 2011, I am once again a sub-30 guy. It feels really good. Now, I’m thinking about where I’m going from here.
Five miles in 29:51 is worth about 18:05 for 5K and 2:53-low for the marathon, according to VDOT. I’d love to be running 17:30 and 2:49, so this doesn’t move the needle much on pure numbers, but we can look at how I’ve run in the past to see what this might be worth for me, specifically.
In 2023, I ran a 2:57 marathon in April, 30:56 at Sunset in June, and a 4:58 mile in July. Taking a minute off that 5-mile time has me feeling good about those other two distances. It has me thinking I’ve lost far less fitness than I expected since Rehoboth and the birth of my son. If I spend the summer building mileage, how far can I go from here? Is a sub-80 half marathon (6:05 pace) possible by fall? Am I on track for sub-2:50 (6:29 pace) by next spring?
I guess we’ll see what happens.